Sunday, June 18, 2006
I was reading (well, re-reading) Heinrich Rommen's "The Natural Law" when I stopped and put the book down when he put forward the idea that that the whole issue of whether there is a natural law or only positive laws depends upon the whether one puts reason above will, or will above reason.
I wanted to quickly answer the priority question, but couldn't. For will is very powerful, and it is the great and awesome gift that enables us to say yes or no to God. But Socrates argument that no one would willing choose what is bad, and that it is all a matter of inability to reason has never quite convinced me. The evidence is too great that even men with great reasoning powers choose to do wrong.
Then it dawned on me, which is why I had to write this down (I will tidy it up later - Mass beckons), God has given us both great gifts (the ability to reason and the will to do) but reason is the pre-eminent gift. Which is why God chooses to reveal Himself in the way He has. He could reveal Himself in ways that would command us, even with our limited reasoning powers to acknowledge Him. But where would the Love be? Where would that act of Will on our part be present? For it is Love that God is and desires.
This one is fascinating me, though the Church probably has given the definitive answer. Whilst having a coffee after Mass it struck me that maybe I was approaching this from the wrong direction - Rommen, I'm sure, said the 'priority' of reason or will; which is not quite the same thing as 'supremacy'. Priority, in this context, might well have been used to distinguish which comes first in an action - the reasoning or the will; which would, in this instance still leave the will as the stronger. By 'stronger' I mean that even if you reasoning powers had firmly attained the truthfulness and 'oughtness' of a course of action, there still is the will to over-ride this and do something false and what one 'ought not'.
Of course, this has to be set against the fact that as a result of the Fall we have impaired reasoning and our will is raging against actions that are good.
Will ponder this more..and pray.
I wanted to quickly answer the priority question, but couldn't. For will is very powerful, and it is the great and awesome gift that enables us to say yes or no to God. But Socrates argument that no one would willing choose what is bad, and that it is all a matter of inability to reason has never quite convinced me. The evidence is too great that even men with great reasoning powers choose to do wrong.
Then it dawned on me, which is why I had to write this down (I will tidy it up later - Mass beckons), God has given us both great gifts (the ability to reason and the will to do) but reason is the pre-eminent gift. Which is why God chooses to reveal Himself in the way He has. He could reveal Himself in ways that would command us, even with our limited reasoning powers to acknowledge Him. But where would the Love be? Where would that act of Will on our part be present? For it is Love that God is and desires.
This one is fascinating me, though the Church probably has given the definitive answer. Whilst having a coffee after Mass it struck me that maybe I was approaching this from the wrong direction - Rommen, I'm sure, said the 'priority' of reason or will; which is not quite the same thing as 'supremacy'. Priority, in this context, might well have been used to distinguish which comes first in an action - the reasoning or the will; which would, in this instance still leave the will as the stronger. By 'stronger' I mean that even if you reasoning powers had firmly attained the truthfulness and 'oughtness' of a course of action, there still is the will to over-ride this and do something false and what one 'ought not'.
Of course, this has to be set against the fact that as a result of the Fall we have impaired reasoning and our will is raging against actions that are good.
Will ponder this more..and pray.